How to Choose a Bicycle Lock

Which Bike Lock Provides the Best Bicycle Security?

© Helen Smeaton

Dec 15, 2008
Kryptonite New York Shackle Lock, Amazon.com
There are many types of bike lock on the market. Here's some advice on the differences between each bicycle lock and which one to choose for the best bike security.

In the UK, 1200 bikes are stolen every day. In New York, a staggering 170 bikes are swiped daily making it the bike theft capital of the world. Investing in a good quality bicycle lock is critical to ensure a bike does not become one of those statistics.

Types of Bike Lock

There are three main categories:

  • Basic cable and chain locks
  • U shape shackle locks
  • Immobiliser loop locks

Which type of bike lock to use largely depends on where the bike is left unattended. Most thefts outside the home are opportunist; the bike thief spots a poorly secured bike or, better still, a bike left alone whilst popping into a shop. Conversely, a bike stolen from home is more likely to be carried out by a determined, experienced thief so will require a different type of bicycle security lock.

Cable and Chain Bike Locks

Cable locks are light and flexible and easy to wrap around other objects like a lamppost to secure the bike. A good quality cable lock should be made of multiple thin braided wires making the cable difficult to cut compared to cheaper models where the wire is thicker and unbraided. The best chain locks are manufactured from thick steel allowing very little space between links; they are therefore much harder to cut.

As both types of lock come in a coiled form they are easy to carry around but cheaper models do not offer good security if leaving a bike either overnight or in an area prone to bicycle theft. Dependent on the length, chain locks can also be very heavy.

Shackle Locks – U Shaped Bike Locks

Shackle locks are made of two sections, a hardened steel U bar which attaches to the housing containing the locking mechanism. Double mechanism locks are best as they secure both ends of the U bar independently and are therefore harder to break.

These locks are far more secure than cable locks but one downside is weight. The other problem with a U shaped lock is that there is limited space for securing to a fixed object and it cannot fix both wheels and the frame together. An additional shackle lock is therefore required to secure both front and back wheels or a cable lock must be used in conjunction with the U lock for complete security.

Immobiliser Loop Locks

These locks are heavy-duty cable locks with a padlock that attach directly to the bike frame. When in use, detach one end of the loop and wrap around the spokes to immobilise the bike. This type of lock is an ideal temporary deterrent when stopping for a few minutes to pop into a shop and is also a good choice to combine with a more secure shackle lock for added security.

Cost of Bicycle Locks

Cheap cable locks start from as little as £4.99 or $10 with heavy duty Kryptonite immobiliser and D shaped locks selling at over £45 or $65.

Choose the Right level of Bike Security

Shackle locks probably provide the best level of bike security for the price and, when used with a loop lock or heavy duty chain lock, offer good protection for bikes left unattended for long periods of time outdoors. Before purchasing a bike lock, it is advisable to read bike lock reviews online to get feedback from other bike owners as to what is best for your particular circumstances.

Related Articles:

For additional advice on bike security, see our tips on bicycle theft prevention and our article on using electronic security tagging as an additional deterrent.


The copyright of the article How to Choose a Bicycle Lock in Bicycle Gear is owned by Helen Smeaton. Permission to republish How to Choose a Bicycle Lock in print or online must be granted by the author in writing.


Kryptonite New York Shackle Lock, Amazon.com
Bell Basic Cable Bike Lock, Amazon.com
Onguard U Shaped Lock with Extra Cable Lock, Amazon.com
Kryptonite Heavy Duty Chain Lock, Amazon.com
Oxford Heavy Duty Loop Lock, ChainReactionCycles.com


Post this Article to facebook Add this Article to del.icio.us! Digg this Article furl this Article Add this Article to Reddit Add this Article to Technorati Add this Article to Newsvine Add this Article to Windows Live Add this Article to Yahoo Add this Article to StumbleUpon Add this Article to BlinkLists Add this Article to Spurl Add this Article to Google Add this Article to Ask Add this Article to Squidoo